Are you aware of the significant changes in the Community Association Institute (CAI)’s recommendations for best practices in future reserve fund studies? If you are not, you are not alone. In July 2023, the Foundation for Community Association Research published its Best Practices – Community Association Maintenance manual. Let me explain why this 68- page ‘Maintenance’ manual should be a must read for every condominium or HOA board member. It is available in printed form and the no cost digital version can be downloaded from CAI’s website.
Most reserve fund studies in the recent past have used CAI’s Best Practices – Reserve Studies / Management manual published in 2007 as a guideline on how to perform a quality reserve fund study. Though this guideline is still relevant, things have changed with the new 2023 ‘Maintenance’ manual. No longer is a reserve fund study’s primary focus budgetary but rather future reserve fund studies should expand to incorporate both safety and preventive maintenance needs. As CAI states, CAI “…recognized need for greater clarity in the role of maintenance planning and programming in communities”.
Following the June 2021 tragedy in Surfside, Florida with the collapse of Champlain Towers South and the loss of 98 occupants, CAI commissioned a special committee of reserve fund experts contributing to the Condominium Safety Public Policy Report (October 2021). Among other points of emphasis was condo boards’ life-safety responsibilities and duties of loyalty and care. The special committee’s ‘Maintenance’ manual further recommends expanding typical reserve components to include preventative maintenance in future reserve fund planning as well as infrastructure inspections when warranted.
This is a departure from prior reserve fund guidelines where preventive maintenance and infrastructure inspections were not included or funded as reserve component line items. It is now recommended the judgement of the reserve study provider determines the inclusion of these types of component items when based on a degree of engineering certainty. It is further suggested the community’s historical pattern of maintenance expenses should be considered in determining if any of these expenses should be included in the reserve budget. Other historical reviews should include any work performed on the reserve components since the prior study was performed. In fact, all available service provider reports and information regarding the physical components should be reviewed.
What’s Included
While reserve studies will now reflect the board’s life-safety responsibilities, reserve studies will continue to evaluate information regarding the physical status and repair/ replacement cost of the association’s major common area components using component inventory, a condition assessment, and valuation estimates. Some of the new ‘Maintenance’ manual’s recommendations are subtle while others are not, such as decreasing the recommended period of site inspections from five to every three years.
Another significant recommendation is components are not restricted to physical items. This could include professional inspections, evaluations, or related building services when additional expert advice is needed, and an asset’s deterioration is in question. Therefore, common area preventive or corrective maintenance projects qualify as reserve components if they otherwise meet the definition of ‘component’. Thus, a reserve component is not required to be a cyclical replacement. Now a periodic structural inspection could be reserve component.
In the past component replacement was estimated as a ‘like kind’ of component. It is now recommended consideration should be given to logical upgrades to an existing asset or system now viewed as obsolete or inefficient in meeting the needs of the association. Judgement on these upgrades can be based on ongoing preventive maintenance costs and an evaluation of energy costs using higher efficiency equipment. Selection of components and their estimated useful life and remaining useful life may consider energy usage and ongoing maintenance costs with the resulting impact on total budgetary expenses and total life cycle costs.
Long-life components (i.e., > 30 years) have long been a subject of debate on their presentation in reserve studies. Often boards ignored long-life infrastructure components, hidden electrical and mechanical systems and their associated replacement costs. In effect, if the component’s replacement did not occur within the reserve study’s 30-year window, the study ignored future funding needs and kicked the can down the road for a future board to address. The new ‘Maintenance’ manual recommends long-life components should not be ignored but made visible in the study. Methodologies for reporting long-term projects include:
Inclusion of long-life components with funding in the study.
Addition of long-life components with funding at the time when they fall within the 30-year period from the date of study preparation.
Identification of long-life components in the component inventory, even when they are not yet being funded in the 30-year funding plan.
Despite this new emphasis on preventive maintenance, it should always be remembered a reserve fund study is not a preventive maintenance plan, and a preventive maintenance plan is recommended for all associations. A quality reserve fund study is a path to avoid deferred maintenance; special assessments; lower property values; and liability exposure for all. This is a plan to meet the board’s primary mandate to ‘Maintain, Protect and Enhance.’
Written by Jack Carr, P.E., R.S., LEED-AP, Senior Consultant Criterium Engineers
Published in Condo Media
homeowner association, reserve study, budget, board of directors, law, condominium, insurance, property, asset, management, roof, inspection, state, hoa management, reserve study company, reserve fund, financial analysis, maintenance, community associations institute, organization, legislation, inventory, data, construction, engineer, inflation, audit, revenue, real estate, company, software, cost, cash, cash flow, security, community, hoa reserve studies, study, community associations, reserves, special, reserve studies, consent, hoa, hoa reserve study, funding, reserve, board, studies, hoa reserves, accounting, experience, accessibility, commercial property, investment, due diligence, regulatory compliance, phase i environmental site assessment, asset management, renovation, building envelope, diligence, expert, fannie mae, freddie mac, project management, services, request, commercial, condition report, loan, lease, elevator, sustainability, energy, zoning, negotiation, communication, deferred maintenance, confidence, procurement, lighting, building code, facility condition assessment, natural disaster, environmental, life safety, due diligence process, environmental compliance, systems, report, facility condition assessments, reports, building, property condition assessments, assessments, assessment, environmental site assessment, property condition report, pcas, pca, commercial building, life safety systems, forensic engineering, retail, understanding, valuation, leed, white paper, real estate transaction, risk assessment, environmental health, expense, finance, hoa management company, community association management, operating fund, rule of thumb, tax, emergency, transparency, sidewalk, fund, funds, community association, property management, financial, hoas, hoa reserve fund, planning, hoa board member, funded, board member, hoa board, hoa board members, reserve study for condo association, hoa reserve study cost, homeowners association reserve study, homeowners association reserve fund, homeowners association reserves, hoa reserve, hoa reserve funds, hoa reserve account
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does my HOA need a reserve study?
The necessity of a reserve study for your HOA lies in its ability to assess and plan for future maintenance and repair costs. This ensures financial stability and helps avoid unexpected special assessments for homeowners.
What does an HOA reserve study company do for the association?
An HOA reserve study company provides essential services to the association by assessing the current condition of common property assets, estimating future repair and replacement costs, and developing a funding plan to ensure financial stability for ongoing maintenance and improvements.
How often should an HOA do a reserve study in Florida?
HOAs in Florida should conduct a reserve study at least every three to five years. This ensures that the association accurately assesses its financial needs for future repairs and replacements, maintaining the property's value and integrity.
What is a reserve study for an HOA?
A reserve study for an HOA is a financial planning tool that assesses the community's long-term repair and replacement needs, helping to determine appropriate reserve funds to ensure the maintenance and sustainability of shared assets.
How to read an HOA reserve study?
Reading an HOA reserve study involves understanding the financial projections for future repairs and replacements of common property elements. Focus on the funding plan, projected expenditures, and the current reserve balance to assess the community's financial health.
How to calculate HOA reserve fund?
Calculating the HOA reserve fund involves estimating the total costs for future repairs and replacements of common area components, then dividing that figure by the expected lifespan of those components to determine annual contributions needed.
Why do HOAs need reserve accounts?
HOAs need reserve accounts to ensure they have sufficient funds for future repairs and maintenance of common areas, preventing financial strain on members and ensuring the community remains well-maintained and attractive.
How often should an HOA do a reserve study?
An HOA should conduct a reserve study every three to five years. This ensures that the association has an accurate assessment of its long-term financial needs for maintenance and replacement of common property assets.
How often does an HOA need to do a reserve study?
HOAs typically need to conduct a reserve study every three to five years. This frequency ensures that the association accurately assesses its financial needs for future repairs and replacements, maintaining the community's property values and overall integrity.
What can HOA reserve funds be used for?
HOA reserve funds can be used for major repairs and replacements of common elements, such as roofs, pools, and landscaping, as well as for unexpected expenses to ensure the community's long-term financial stability.
What is a healthy HOA reserve?
A healthy HOA reserve is a fund that is adequately funded to cover future maintenance, repairs, and replacements of common property elements, typically amounting to 10-30% of the total budget, ensuring financial stability for the community.
What factors influence HOA reserve study frequency?
The factors that influence HOA reserve study frequency include the age and condition of the property, changes in maintenance costs, significant repairs or improvements, and state regulations or requirements. These elements help determine how often a reserve study should be conducted to ensure financial stability.
How is an HOA reserve fund calculated?
The calculation of an HOA reserve fund involves estimating the future repair and replacement costs of common property elements, assessing their useful life, and determining the appropriate funding level to ensure financial stability for the community.
What are common expenses in HOA reserves?
Common expenses in HOA reserves include maintenance and repair of common areas, landscaping, insurance, and replacement of major components like roofs and elevators. These costs ensure the community remains well-maintained and financially stable.
How can an HOA improve its reserve fund?
An HOA can improve its reserve fund by conducting regular assessments of property needs, establishing a clear funding plan, and increasing contributions from homeowners to ensure adequate savings for future repairs and replacements.
What is the purpose of an HOA reserve study?
The purpose of an HOA reserve study is to assess the long-term financial health of a homeowners association by evaluating the condition of common property elements and determining the necessary funding for future repairs and replacements.
How do reserve studies benefit HOA members?
The benefits of reserve studies for HOA members are significant. They provide a comprehensive assessment of community assets, helping to ensure adequate funding for future repairs and maintenance, ultimately promoting financial stability and preserving property values.
What should be included in a reserve study?
A reserve study should include an inventory of the community's major components, their condition assessments, estimated remaining useful life, replacement costs, and a funding plan to ensure adequate reserves for future repairs and replacements.
How often should reserve studies be updated?
Reserve studies should be updated every three to five years or whenever significant changes occur in the property, such as major repairs or alterations, to ensure accurate financial planning and maintenance assessments.
What are the consequences of inadequate reserves?
The consequences of inadequate reserves can lead to financial strain on property owners, resulting in insufficient funds for necessary repairs, increased special assessments, and potential declines in property value.
How do reserve studies impact HOA budgeting?
Reserve studies significantly impact HOA budgeting by providing a detailed assessment of future repair and replacement costs. This enables HOAs to allocate appropriate funds, ensuring financial stability and preventing unexpected expenses.
What is the role of a reserve study company?
The role of a reserve study company is to evaluate and analyze a property's long-term maintenance needs and financial planning. They provide detailed reports that help homeowners associations and property managers allocate funds for future repairs and replacements effectively.
How can an HOA assess its reserve needs?
An HOA can assess its reserve needs by conducting a comprehensive reserve study, which evaluates the current condition of assets, estimates future repair and replacement costs, and determines the appropriate funding level to maintain those assets effectively.
What is the difference between reserves and operating funds?
The difference between reserves and operating funds is that reserves are designated for future capital expenditures or emergencies, while operating funds are used for day-to-day expenses and regular maintenance of the property.
How do reserve studies affect property values?
Reserve studies significantly influence property values by providing a clear assessment of a property's future maintenance and repair needs. This transparency assures potential buyers that the property is well-managed, ultimately enhancing its marketability and value.
What guidelines exist for HOA reserve studies?
Guidelines for HOA reserve studies include following industry standards, such as the National Association of Realtors (NAR) recommendations, ensuring accurate assessments of property components, and conducting regular updates to reflect changes in property conditions and financial needs.
How can technology assist in reserve studies?
Technology enhances reserve studies by streamlining data collection, analysis, and reporting processes. It enables accurate forecasting of future repair and replacement costs, ensuring informed decision-making for property managers and homeowners associations.
What are the best practices for reserve funding?
The best practices for reserve funding include regularly assessing and updating funding needs, establishing a clear funding goal based on a reserve study, and consistently contributing to the reserve fund to ensure adequate resources for future maintenance and repairs.
How do state laws affect HOA reserves?
State laws significantly impact HOA reserves by establishing requirements for reserve funding, maintenance, and reporting. These regulations ensure that associations maintain adequate financial resources for future repairs and replacements, promoting fiscal responsibility and property value preservation.
What challenges do HOAs face with reserve studies?
The challenges HOAs face with reserve studies include accurately assessing property needs, ensuring adequate funding for future repairs, and navigating member expectations. These factors can complicate the planning and budgeting process essential for maintaining community assets.
criterium engineers, structural engineer st louis, structural engineer report near me, hoa engineering report
Criterium-Hardy Engineers: Your Trusted Engineering Consultants
At Criterium-Hardy Engineers, we specialize in providing high-quality engineering consulting services tailored to meet the unique needs of homeowners associations, residential properties, and commercial entities. Our expertise covers a wide range of services, including reserve studies, property condition assessments, and structural evaluations, ensuring that our clients receive comprehensive solutions for their engineering challenges.
Founded in 1986, our team of licensed professional engineers brings over 30 years of experience to the table. We pride ourselves on our commitment to quality, reliability, and client satisfaction, making us a preferred choice for engineering consulting in Missouri and Illinois.
Comprehensive Engineering Services
Criterium-Hardy Engineers offers a diverse array of engineering services designed to address the specific needs of various clients. From HOA reserve studies that help associations plan for future expenses to detailed property condition assessments that provide insights into the state of commercial buildings, our services are tailored to ensure that clients make informed decisions regarding their properties.
Our engineering services also include structural evaluations, feasibility studies, and project management, all conducted by experienced professionals. By leveraging our knowledge and expertise, we help clients navigate complex engineering issues and achieve their goals efficiently and effectively.
Why Choose Criterium-Hardy Engineers?
Choosing Criterium-Hardy Engineers means opting for a team that prioritizes your needs and delivers results. Our engineers are not only licensed professionals but also certified inspectors and LEED accredited professionals, ensuring that we adhere to the highest industry standards in all our projects. Our reputation for thoroughness and reliability sets us apart in the engineering consulting field.
We understand that every project is unique, which is why we take the time to listen to our clients and tailor our services accordingly. Our commitment to providing fast, reliable service ensures that you receive the support you need, when you need it, making us the go-to choice for engineering consulting in your area.
Client-Centric Approach
At Criterium-Hardy Engineers, we place a strong emphasis on client satisfaction. Our approach is centered around understanding your specific requirements and delivering customized solutions that exceed your expectations. We believe that open communication and transparency are key to fostering successful client relationships.
Our testimonials reflect our dedication to service excellence and the trust our clients place in us. By focusing on your needs and maintaining high standards throughout our process, we ensure that you receive the best possible outcomes for your engineering projects.
How to Request Our Services
Requesting services from Criterium-Hardy Engineers is a straightforward process designed to save you time and effort. Whether you need a reserve study, property condition assessment, or any other engineering service, our user-friendly interface allows you to easily submit your request online. Simply fill out the service request form, and our team will get back to you promptly.
Additionally, we offer options for clients to pay invoices online, simplifying the transaction process. Our goal is to make your experience as seamless as possible, allowing you to focus on your property while we handle the engineering details.
